Eat like a New Yorker without breaking the bank
New York City mornings buzz with possibilities — from street-side bagels to cozy diners and hidden bakeries. But with rising prices and tourist traps on every block, finding an authentic, wallet-friendly breakfast can feel like a scavenger hunt. Whether you’re a student, a traveler, or a local on a budget, this Budget-Friendly Breakfast NYC guide will help you enjoy the city’s best morning flavors — without spending a fortune.
How We Picked These Spots
This list isn’t random. We chose each breakfast spot based on:
- Local recommendations and foodie forums
- Dishes under $12 that don’t compromise on flavor
- Neighborhood favorites with authentic NYC vibes
- Strong Google or Yelp reviews (4.2+ rating)
We even visited a few of these ourselves — and trust us, you’ll want to go back again.
Who Is This Guide For?
If you’re:
- A student or traveler seeking cheap eats
- Someone craving local breakfast classics
- Visiting NYC for the first time and don’t want to waste money
- A resident tired of overpriced brunch menus
Then this guide is built for you.
6 Spots for Budget-Friendly Breakfast NYC
1. Tompkins Square Bagels – East Village
Average Price: $7–$10
Must-Try: Everything Bagel with Scallion Cream Cheese or Pastrami Lox
Hours: Daily, 7:00 AM – 4:00 PM
Location: 184 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10003, United States
Phone Number: +19174727639
Website: http://tompkinssquarebagels.com/
📍 Why Go:
Tompkins Square Bagels isn’t just a place to grab a bite — it’s an East Village institution. Famous for their giant, hand-rolled bagels that are both chewy and crisped just right, this local gem offers over 20 types of cream cheeses and inventive fillings like wasabi lox or birthday cake schmear. The everything bagel, paired with scallion cream cheese or pastrami lox, is a rite of passage for breakfast lovers in NYC.
🧠 Local Tip:
Skip the indoor tables — take your bagel to Tompkins Square Park, just steps away, and enjoy a peaceful breakfast under the trees or by the dog run. It’s a favorite neighborhood ritual, especially on sunny mornings.
🌟 Budget-Friendly Bonus:
Despite being a hotspot, prices stay wallet-friendly. You’ll leave full, satisfied, and ready to explore more of the East Village food scene — no brunch reservation or $20 avocado toast required.
📌 Great For:
- Foodies seeking authentic NYC bagels
- Budget travelers exploring East Village
- Breakfast lovers on the go
- Tourists looking to eat like locals
2. B&H Dairy – Timeless Kosher Comfort in East Village
Average Price: $8
Must-Try: Challah French Toast or Classic Eggs with Home Fries
Hours: Daily, 8:00 AM – 9:00 PM
Location: 127 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10003, United States
Phone Number: +12125058065
Website: https://www.bandhdairykosher.com/
📍 Why Go:
Step into a slice of old New York at B&H Dairy, a legendary kosher-style diner that’s been serving East Village locals since the 1940s. This tiny, no-frills spot is cherished for its warm hospitality, nostalgic atmosphere, and ultra-satisfying vegetarian fare. Their challah French toast is fluffy, golden, and generously portioned, while the eggs and home fries combo hits all the right comfort notes — filling, affordable, and served with love.
✨ What makes B&H special is its resilience — surviving blackouts, neighborhood change, and even a fire, the diner stands as a symbol of East Village grit and charm.
🧠 Local Tip:
Snag a stool at the narrow lunch counter for the full vintage diner vibe. Watch the grill in action while chatting with regulars and staff — it’s a NYC breakfast moment you won’t forget.
🌿 Vegetarian Bonus:
The entire menu is vegetarian-friendly, with tons of Eastern European classics like pierogis, soups, and knishes — great if you’re skipping meat but craving depth of flavor.
📌 Great For:
- Lovers of classic NYC diners
- Budget-friendly breakfast or brunch seekers
- Vegetarians wanting hearty morning meals
- Travelers chasing authentic NYC experiences
3. Ess-a-Bagel – Legendary, Loaded Bagels in Midtown East
Average Price: $6–$11
Must-Try: Bagel with Nova Lox and Cream Cheese
Hours: Daily, 6:00 AM – 3:00 PM
Location: 831 3rd Ave, New York, NY 10022, United States
Phone Number: +12129801010
Website: https://www.ess-a-bagel.com/
📍 Why Go:
Ess-a-Bagel isn’t just a bagel shop — it’s a New York City institution. Since 1976, it’s been drawing locals, tourists, and bagel purists alike with its enormous, chewy, perfectly boiled bagels and mountain-high spreads. Whether you’re a traditionalist who swears by lox and cream cheese, or someone who likes to build a full deli sandwich on a sesame bagel, this is your carb-happy heaven.
The Nova Lox combo is a star — silky, salty, and rich, paired with tangy cream cheese and the bakery-fresh bagel of your choice. Portion sizes are massive: most visitors are stunned to find that one bagel can easily serve two.
🧠 Local Tip:
Avoid the crowds by steering clear of the 8:00–9:30 AM rush. For a quicker visit, order online and skip the sometimes intimidating line altogether.
🥯 Customization Heaven:
From tofu spreads to whitefish salad, capers, red onion, and more — the topping bar is nearly endless. You’ll find choices for vegans, vegetarians, and picky eaters alike.
📌 Great For:
- Serious bagel lovers
- Big appetites and sharable breakfasts
- Classic NYC breakfast experiences
- Midtown hotel guests or morning commuters
4. Peter Pan Donut & Pastry Shop – A Brooklyn Classic with Sweet Fame
Average Price: $3–$6
Must-Try: Red Velvet Donut or Bacon-Egg-Cheese on a Roll
Hours: Daily, 4:30 AM – 8:00 PM
Location: 727 Manhattan Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11222, United States
Phone Number: +17183893676
Website: http://peterpandonuts.com/
📍 Why Go:
Step into a 1950s time capsule with Peter Pan Donut & Pastry Shop — a Greenpoint institution beloved by locals, tourists, and even celebrities (yes, Taylor Swift has been spotted here!). This no-frills bakery serves fresh, hand-made donuts that are as photogenic as they are delicious. From red velvet to maple bacon, each donut is pillowy soft, perfectly glazed, and just the right amount of sweet.
Beyond donuts, the shop is known for its bacon-egg-cheese on a fluffy roll — a legit NYC-style breakfast sandwich for under $5. The retro uniforms, spinning stools, and warm service only add to the charm.
🧠 Local Tip:
Avoid the weekend donut rush. Visit before 9 AM on a weekday for the freshest picks and shortest line.
🍽️ What Sets It Apart:
- Vintage soda-fountain vibes
- Handmade donuts made fresh daily
- Super-affordable breakfast sandwiches
- Cash-only, so come prepared!
📌 Great For:
- Brooklyn foodies and donut lovers
- Vintage café enthusiasts
- Budget breakfasts with character
- Greenpoint walking tours and coffee breaks
5. La Bonbonniere – A No-Frills, Cash-Only West Village Gem
Average Price: Around $10
Must-Try: Fluffy Pancakes or the Hearty Western Omelet
Hours: 7:00 AM – 3:00 PM Daily
Location: 28 8th Ave, New York, NY 10014, United States
Phone Number: +12127419266
Website: http://www.instagram.com/labonbonnierenyc
📍 Why Go:
Hidden in plain sight on a quiet West Village street, La Bonbonniere is a classic New York greasy spoon that’s remained nearly unchanged since the 1980s. Inside, you’ll find formica tables, celebrity-signed photos, and the comforting aroma of bacon and coffee. It’s where locals, artists, and even celebs like Jake Gyllenhaal come for a cheap and satisfying breakfast — often under $10.
Their pancakes are pillowy, buttery, and slightly crispy on the edges, while the Western omelet is loaded with ham, peppers, and onions — all served with home fries and toast.
🧠 Local Tip:
It’s cash-only, so come prepared. And if the small space is packed (which it often is), sit at the counter for faster service and better diner banter.
🍽️ What Sets It Apart:
- No Wi-Fi, no nonsense — just fast service and big portions
- A nostalgic throwback with loyal regulars
- Frequent celebrity sightings
- Perfect spot after a West Village morning stroll
📌 Great For:
- Budget travelers craving an authentic NYC breakfast
- Fans of vintage diners and classic American fare
- Quick brunches before heading to the Hudson or The High Line
- Pancake lovers on a mission
6. Leo’s Bagels – A Financial District Favorite for Fresh, Chewy Bagels
Average Price: $6–$9
Must-Try: Whole Wheat Everything Bagel with Whitefish Salad
Hours: 6:30 AM – 3:30 PM (Monday–Friday)
Location: 3 Hanover Square, New York, NY 10004, United States
Phone Number: +12127854700
Website: https://leosbagels.com/
📍 Why Go:
Nestled in a historic stone building in the Financial District, Leo’s Bagels is a local gem that consistently serves some of the chewiest, freshest bagels in Lower Manhattan. Known for its crunchy exterior and soft, doughy center, their bagels are made the old-fashioned way — boiled and baked daily.
It’s a go-to breakfast spot for Wall Street professionals, but equally beloved by tourists craving a real New York bagel. From scallion cream cheese to baked salmon and whitefish salad, their spread variety is unmatched.
🧠 Local Tip:
Skip the line by ordering online and choosing “pickup.” It saves serious time during the morning rush, especially between 8:00–9:30 AM.
🍽️ What Sets It Apart:
- Bagels are hand-rolled and made fresh daily
- Wide selection of spreads and toppings (including multiple smoked fish options)
- Located near iconic spots like Wall Street and Battery Park
- Efficient online ordering system for quick grab-and-go
📌 Great For:
- Quick breakfast before a ferry ride or finance meeting
- Whitefish salad lovers
- Anyone staying in the Financial District looking for a quality NYC bagel
Last Updated: August 2025
We refresh this list every few months to ensure it reflects current prices, crowd trends, and opening hours. Got a favorite spot that deserves a mention? Drop us a comment below.
FAQ’s
Q: Can I find breakfast under $5 in NYC?
Yes! Try Peter Pan Donuts or grab a classic bagel and coffee combo at a local cart.
Q: Are these breakfast places vegetarian-friendly?
Most of them are! B&H Dairy is fully vegetarian. Others offer egg-and-cheese or veggie bagel options.
Q: What’s the best time to go?
Before 9 AM on weekdays is ideal. Weekends tend to be busier, especially at diners and bagel shops.
💬 Your Turn — Got a Hidden Gem?
Did we miss your favorite cheap breakfast spot in NYC? Comment below or send us a tip — and we might feature it in our next update!
Be First to Comment